Judge Gives Animal Abusers a Taste of Their Own Medicine Instead of Giving Them a Slap on the Wrist
Judge Michael Cicconetti built a reputation in Painesville, Ohio, for handing down punishments that were hard to forget. In animal cruelty cases, he often chose sentences that mirrored the harm defendants caused, and that made his courtroom stand out fast.
The retired judge did not hand out dangerous or illegal penalties, but he did make sure the lesson felt personal. From abandoned kittens to neglected dogs, his unusual rulings were designed to stick with the people who caused the damage.
Some of those sentences were so unusual that people still talk about them today. Read on.
Judge Cicconetti used to give out very innovative sentences where the penalty truly fit the crime
He made a woman who left 35 kittens in the woods spend a night alone in the forest.
A woman who kept her dog in dirt and filth had to spend a day in the city dump.
The judge is talking to the defendant here:
What exactly were these sentences?
In one case, a woman dumped 35 kittens in the woods. He condemned her to spend a night in the forest. Here’s what he said to her during sentencing: “How would you like to be dumped off at a metro park late at night, spend the night listening to the coyotes, listening to the raccoons around you in the dark, and sit out there in the cold not knowing where you’re going to get your next meal, not knowing when you are going to be rescued?”
The judge sentenced a woman whose dog was living in appalling conditions to spend a day at the local dump. “I want you to go down to the county dump, to the landfill, and I want them to find the stinkiest, smelliest, God-awful odor place they can find in that dump, and I want you to sit there for eight hours tomorrow, to think about what you did to that dog while you smell the odor. If you puke, you puke.”
That was only the beginning.
Judge Cicconetti started giving these kinds of sentences after he realized that jail time doesn’t really teach offenders a lesson and only leads to repeated crime. He tries to make the punishment fit the crime.
The judge adores animals. Currently, he owns a 10-year-old Bernese Mountain Dog named Kasey.
His other unusual sentences are:
- A man who was arrested for child abuse had to go to a school in a dog costume and talk about child well-being.
- A man arrested with a loaded gun had to go to the morgue to look at the corpses.
- A young man who stole a bicycle had to ride a bike in support of a local charity for the next ten days.
- A man who shot a dog was instructed to donate 40 lbs of dog food on every public holiday to the Lake County Animal Shelter.
- Two teens who wrote 666 on a nativity figure of Jesus had to walk a donkey across the streets with a sign saying: “Sorry for the jackass offense, but he is soooo cute!”
- Teens who deflated tires on school buses were sentenced to throw a picnic for the primary school children whose field trip was canceled because of the prank.
- A man who was arrested for a traffic violation during which he shouted “pigs” at police officers was sentenced to stay on the street with a 350-pound pig and a sign that said, “This is not a police officer.”
- A teenage male who stole pornography from an adult bookstore was sentenced to sit outside the store with a blindfold and hold a sign that read, “See no evil.”
- Three grown men soliciting sex were ordered to wear chicken costumes while holding signs that said “No Chicken Ranch in Painesville.”
- In January 2008, Cicconetti punished a man who stole a red collection kettle wit...[truncated]
It’s a similar power struggle to the dog trainer who cut off entitled pet owners, charging extra.
People still debate whether these punishments were fair, but they definitely got attention.
Internet users believe that the judge’s sentences were appropriate.
And if you think that’s wild, see how a woman rewarded dogs for barring roommates’ teeth.
Share this article:
