logo
Funny Animals Interesting Freaky Pop Culture

People Are Claiming That Mary Poppins Was Actually A Racist Film Due To A "Black Face" Scene

by Elana

The 1964 Disney classic, Mary Poppins, has most definitely been considered a beloved classic spanning multiple generations. Few of us could say we can't recall watching the musical movie as children. In fact, Mary Poppins as character is quite frankly one of the sweetest, most endearing, child-loving, fictional characters of all time.

The musical movie has long-since been considered a masterpiece and the songs featured in the film have certainly stood the test of time. Almost anyone today could still easily sing a few lines from "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious," and "A Spoonful of Sugar..." (helps the medicine go down!) Unfortunately, despite the 2018 "Mary Poppins Returns" reminding us all how much we seriously love this character and story, Mary Poppins has not managed to escape controversy.

If you haven't heard about it yet, you might find yourself surprised, but a controversy has erupted over whether or not the Chimney Sweep scene in Mary Poppins is racist.

If you haven't heard about it yet, you might find yourself surprised, but a controversy has erupted over whether or not the Chimney Sweep scene in Mary Poppins is racist. Disney

Where did this controversy erupt from?

It all began when Professor Daniel Pollack-Pelzner, an English and gender studies professor at Oregon’s Linfield College, wrote an article published in the New York Times entitled "Mary Poppins and a Nanny’s Shameful Flirting With Blackface." In his article he brings us to the original movie's scene where Mary and Bert bring Jane and Michael on a musical tour of London's rooftops. Tagging along are Bert's chimney sweep friends and everyone, Mary and kids included, is covered in soot. At one point, Mary attempts to wipe soot off of her face but when she only makes it worse, she shrugs it off and adds more soot to her nose and cheeks on purpose.

So what is Pollack-Pelzner's argument? He believes the scene is attempting to draw a humorous comparison between the chimney sweeps’ blackened faces and racial caricatures, such as those seen in black minstrel shows, also known as "Black Face."

In an expert from his article, Pollack-Pelzner writes:

The 1964 film replays this racial panic in a farcical key. When the dark figures of the chimney sweeps step in time on a roof, a naval buffoon, Admiral Boom, shouts, 'We’re being attacked by Hottentots!' and orders his cannon to be fired at the 'cheeky devils.'We’re in on the joke, such as it is: These aren’t really black Africans; they’re grinning white dancers in blackface. It’s a parody of black menace; it’s even posted on a white nationalist website as evidence of the film’s racial hierarchy. And it’s not only fools like the Admiral who invoke this language.

Adding:

Blackface minstrelsy, in fact, could be said to be part of Disney’s origin story ... Disney has long evoked minstrelsy for its topsy-turvy entertainments — a nanny blacking up, chimney sweeps mocking the upper classes, grinning lamplighters turning work into song.Times Union

Pollack-Pelzner's message did not resonate well with the bulk majority of Internet users and many lashed out towards him. In response, he shared a social media update:

The chief reason I wrote this article was the hope that a Disney exec would read it, take another look at the forthcoming Dumbo remake, and ask if there was anything just a little bit racist they might want to rethink before it hits the big screen. Here’s one thing I’ve learned about the alt-right, after I wrote this article and received a zillion hate messages in response: they sure like Mary Poppins!

It would seem that while the article author's intentions were well-meant, the bulk majority of people simply aren't buying his narrative. What do you think?

USA Today

Share this article:

Facebook icon Pinterest icon Tumblr icon Link icon Twitter icon

Related Articles

Screentime Is About To Be Lit With These Movies Coming To Disney+ And Hulu This October

Screentime Is About To Be Lit With These Movies Coming To Disney+ And Hulu This October

21 Timeless Final Lines From Your Favorite Disney Films

21 Timeless Final Lines From Your Favorite Disney Films

10 Mind-Blowing Disneyland Secrets That Will Make You See The Park Differently

10 Mind-Blowing Disneyland Secrets That Will Make You See The Park Differently

Disney Breaks New Ground By Debuting Their Seventh Cruise Ship From Never-Before-Sailed Continent

Disney Breaks New Ground By Debuting Their Seventh Cruise Ship From Never-Before-Sailed Continent

Check Out The Darker Side Of Your Beloved Disney Princesses You Never Knew Could Exist

Check Out The Darker Side Of Your Beloved Disney Princesses You Never Knew Could Exist

Fallen Princesses—Photographer Reimagines Disney Princesses' Lives Without The "Happily Ever After"

Fallen Princesses—Photographer Reimagines Disney Princesses' Lives Without The "Happily Ever After"

Rachel Zegler Claps Back At Criticism Over Snow White And Comments On Toxic Disney Fans

Rachel Zegler Claps Back At Criticism Over Snow White And Comments On Toxic Disney Fans

People Reveal The Most Disturbing Disney Scenes That Should Come With A Caution

People Reveal The Most Disturbing Disney Scenes That Should Come With A Caution

‘Even Stevens’ Cast And Crew Spill Surprising Disney Channel On-Set Secrets, And They’re Totally Wild

‘Even Stevens’ Cast And Crew Spill Surprising Disney Channel On-Set Secrets, And They’re Totally Wild

Momfluencer Slammed For Planning Trip To Disney World Orlando Amid Mass Evacuations In That Area

Momfluencer Slammed For Planning Trip To Disney World Orlando Amid Mass Evacuations In That Area

Disney Lovers Share 20 Of Their Most Valuable Disney Park Travel Hacks

Disney Lovers Share 20 Of Their Most Valuable Disney Park Travel Hacks

Disney World's Estimated Losses After Hurricane Milton Forces Shutdown

Disney World's Estimated Losses After Hurricane Milton Forces Shutdown

Sebastian Stan On Marvel, Bucky Barnes, And Why ‘Tom Cruise Is Not A Normal Person’

Sebastian Stan On Marvel, Bucky Barnes, And Why ‘Tom Cruise Is Not A Normal Person’

Mickey Mouse Calls Out Distracted Dad For Ignoring His Kid At Disneyland

Mickey Mouse Calls Out Distracted Dad For Ignoring His Kid At Disneyland

This 'Serial Bride' Has Had Five Disney-Themed Weddings And Is Already Planning Her Next One

This 'Serial Bride' Has Had Five Disney-Themed Weddings And Is Already Planning Her Next One

Princess Diaries 3 Is Finally Happening—Returns With New Director After 20-Year Wait

Princess Diaries 3 Is Finally Happening—Returns With New Director After 20-Year Wait

Couple Insult Evil Queen In Disneyland Over Her Appearance, She Gives Them The Side-Eye And Stays In Character

Couple Insult Evil Queen In Disneyland Over Her Appearance, She Gives Them The Side-Eye And Stays In Character

‘Star Wars’ Had An Alternate Plot Twist That Could’ve Changed The Entire Franchise Forever

‘Star Wars’ Had An Alternate Plot Twist That Could’ve Changed The Entire Franchise Forever

Say ‘I Do’ In The Most Magical Place On Earth—Here Are 15 Disney Spots To Consider

Say ‘I Do’ In The Most Magical Place On Earth—Here Are 15 Disney Spots To Consider

Disney Pushes Star Wars Aside To Give Ice Age 6 The Spotlight

Disney Pushes Star Wars Aside To Give Ice Age 6 The Spotlight

Disney’s New Tiana’s Bayou Adventure Ride Has Fans Soaked And Divided

Disney’s New Tiana’s Bayou Adventure Ride Has Fans Soaked And Divided

Lindsay Lohan Recounts The Savage Swipe She Took At Disney CEO At Age 12 During Parent Trap Premiere

Lindsay Lohan Recounts The Savage Swipe She Took At Disney CEO At Age 12 During Parent Trap Premiere

21 Epic Throwback Posts That’ll Transport You Straight Back To The ‘90s

21 Epic Throwback Posts That’ll Transport You Straight Back To The ‘90s

‘Moana 2’ Soundtrack Just Dropped, And This Catchy Tune From Dwayne Johnson’s ‘Maui’ Is Already A Smash Hit

‘Moana 2’ Soundtrack Just Dropped, And This Catchy Tune From Dwayne Johnson’s ‘Maui’ Is Already A Smash Hit

Family Buys $10,000 In Disneyland Gift Cards And Realizes They’re For Disney+ Instead

Family Buys $10,000 In Disneyland Gift Cards And Realizes They’re For Disney+ Instead

The 'Deadpool & Wolverine' Joke That Disney Cut From The Movie Has Finally Been Revealed—And It’s Wild

The 'Deadpool & Wolverine' Joke That Disney Cut From The Movie Has Finally Been Revealed—And It’s Wild

Categories

Funny Animals Interesting Freaky Pop Culture

Business

About Us Advertise Contact Us

Legal

Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy DMCA Removal
 Logo
About Us Privacy DMCA Removal Contact Us Terms Funny Animals Interesting Freaky Pop Culture

© 2025 - All Rights Reserved

 logo

Sign In to

facebook icon Sign in with facebook
facebook icon Sign in with google

Or sign in with email

Need an account? Sign Up

Forgot Password?

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service

 logo

Sign Up to

Already have an account? Sign In

By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service

Edit profile

User Photo