Should I Wear Black Lace as a Bridesmaid Despite the Wedding Theme? AITA?

AITA for insisting on wearing a black lace dress as a bridesmaid, defying the wedding theme, and causing a rift with the bride over sentimental value?

Damjan

Published in Interesting
August 7, 2025

Should I Wear Black Lace as a Bridesmaid Despite the Wedding Theme? AITA?

Are you the type to stick to your guns or go with the flow, especially when it comes to a friend's big day? Picture this: you're a bridesmaid at your friend Emily's dreamy garden-themed wedding, all pastels and romance.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

She requests light, flowy dresses to match the theme, but you have this gorgeous black lace number that holds sentimental value from your goth teen era. It's your go-to confidence booster.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

When you proposed wearing the black lace dress, Emily tried to compromise with another outfit in line with the theme. But you stood firm, explaining the significance of your dress.

Emily's feeling a bit miffed, calling you cold and controlling, even threatening to skip her own wedding if you don that black lace. The dilemma is real: cling to the past with your meaningful dress or support Emily's vision without causing a bridal showdown.

The Reddit community has some thoughts on the matter. Opinions range from labeling you as the antagonist for potentially clashing with the theme to empathizing with your attachment to the dress.

Some say weddings should prioritize the couple's vision, while others argue for honoring personal significance. It's a debate as old as time - tradition versus individuality, theme cohesion versus personal expression.

Where do you stand? Would you be the AITA in this scenario?

Original Post

So I'm (29F) going to be a bridesmaid at my friend Emily's wedding. She's planning a beautiful garden-themed wedding with pastel colors and a romantic vibe.

Emily asked all of us bridesmaids to wear light, flowy dresses that fit the theme. Here's where the issue starts: I have this beautiful black lace dress that holds sentimental value from our goth teen years.

It's stunning on me and makes me feel confident. When I suggested wearing it as a bridesmaid, Emily offered a compromise with a different outfit that still matched the theme.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

I declined, explaining the significance of the black lace dress to me. Emily tried to accommodate me, but I insisted on the black lace.

Now, she's calling me cold and controlling, saying I'm not respecting her wedding vision. She even threatened to skip the wedding entirely if I wear the black lace dress.

Now, I'm torn. The dress means a lot to me, but I don't want to ruin Emily's big day.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

So AITA?