People Share Their Opinions On Dog Breeds That Should Have Never Existed
Watching your best four-legged friend struggle is one of the most painful experiences a pet owner can endure. Despite all your tender, loving care, health issues can plague the life of your dear pet.
But that's all part of life, and disease and illness can affect any one of us. We just have to accept it because it is all part of the Grand Design.
Is it? One Redditor asked, “If you had to erase one dog breed forever, as if they never even existed, which dog breed would it be?”
And even though this question sounds a bit cruel, it is not. Essentially, preventing some breeds from being created is actually a humane thing to do.
How come? Well, it’s all about dog history.
We have been together for millennia, and all the while, people have been creating new breeds. But the motives are important.
Because motives bring characteristics. For instance, there were no vets back then, so you would want your dog to be healthy and vital.
It should give birth to healthy puppies without any assistance. Depending on the area, it had to have a thick or thin coat, a waterproof fur layer, and be able to run for miles on mountainous terrain.
You get the picture – every characteristic had its use. But the most important thing was – dogs had to be healthy and in tune with their general breed characteristics.
These days, the only characteristic needed is for dogs to be – cute. And that logic has given birth to many dog breeds that couldn’t survive even a year on their own, without special diets, veterinary care, etc.
Just look at pugs and other flat-faced breeds. Namely, they can’t breathe properly.
Can you imagine not being able to breathe? German Shepherds, on the other hand, are now bred to have sloped backs, which increases the likelihood of them developing hip dysplasia.
Take a look at the comments people shared:
Someone asked:
This is the first breed that usually comes to people's minds. And there is a reason for it...
The whole breed is prone to a wide range of illnesses.
When discussing dog breeds that may cause health issues, it’s essential to understand the psychological concept of cognitive dissonance. Cognitive dissonance occurs when individuals hold conflicting beliefs or attitudes, which can lead to discomfort and a desire to rationalize their views. For example, a dog lover might adore certain breeds but simultaneously recognize that these breeds are prone to severe health problems due to breeding practices. Research by Dr. Leon Festinger, the psychologist who first introduced cognitive dissonance theory, suggests that people often resolve this dissonance by downplaying the negative aspects or emphasizing the positive traits of these breeds. This behavior illustrates how emotional attachments can sometimes cloud objective judgment, leading individuals to defend breeding choices that may not prioritize animal welfare.
Addressing this dissonance involves fostering awareness and promoting education about responsible breeding practices, enabling dog lovers to make informed decisions while still cherishing their beloved pets.
Finally, a significant psychological aspect of this conversation is the concept of post-traumatic growth, particularly in relation to pet loss. Owners who have experienced the struggle of a pet’s health issues may develop a heightened awareness of animal welfare and become advocates for change. Research published in the Journal of Loss and Trauma shows that individuals can find new meaning and purpose in their experiences of grief through advocacy work. This transformative process can inspire others to reconsider their choices regarding dog breeds and breeding practices, leading to broader societal change.
Encouraging individuals who have lost pets to channel their grief into positive action can be an empowering strategy. Support groups that focus on advocacy and education can help former pet owners turn their experiences into a force for promoting better practices in dog breeding and ownership.
The Impact of Breeding Practices
Discussions about dog breeds that should not exist often stem from concerns about ethical breeding practices. Research in animal genetics has highlighted that selective breeding can lead to serious health issues, such as hip dysplasia, breathing difficulties, and heart problems.
According to the American Veterinary Medical Association, certain breeds face higher risks of inherited disorders, raising important ethical questions about the responsibility of breeders and owners.
The most obvious health issue is their inability to breathe properly.
And it's because we've made them that way.
People hate to see them suffer
Dr. John Paul, a veterinary behaviorist, observes that many dog owners may not fully comprehend the implications of breed-related health issues. Research published in the Journal of Veterinary Behavior indicates that emotional attachment to a breed can sometimes overshadow rational decision-making. This attachment often leads to what psychologists refer to as 'confirmation bias'—the tendency to seek out information that supports one’s existing beliefs while ignoring evidence to the contrary. For example, a person might focus on the playful nature of a breed while dismissing studies that detail their susceptibility to specific health problems.
Encouraging dog owners to engage in critical reflection about their choices can be an effective strategy. Workshops or seminars that provide balanced information about various breeds and their health risks can empower owners to choose breeds that align better with their values and the welfare of the animals.
It's essential to consider the psychological impact of breed-specific legislation and the stigma associated with certain breeds. Social psychology research suggests that labeling can lead to negative perceptions and discrimination, which can affect both the animals and their owners. According to Dr. Alfie Kohn, an education expert, "Labels can create a self-fulfilling prophecy, leading to behaviors that reinforce the stigma." Furthermore, Dr. Barry Schwartz, a choice researcher, emphasizes that "negative stereotypes can cloud judgment and lead to unwarranted fears, not just about dogs but in many aspects of life." These insights highlight the importance of addressing biases that can arise from breed labeling.
Teacup-size dogs
Some Redditors shared their experiences:
German Shepherds are also in danger because of the twisted standards.
One fascinating aspect of the discussion around dog breeds is the concept of anthropomorphism—the tendency to attribute human characteristics and emotions to animals. Studies show that this tendency can lead to unrealistic expectations of dogs, which can, in turn, affect how owners perceive behavior and health outcomes. For instance, a study published in Psychological Science highlights that pet owners often misinterpret their dogs' stress responses as signs of disobedience or malice, rather than recognizing them as indications of discomfort or anxiety. This misunderstanding can lead to frustration and poor training practices that exacerbate behavioral issues.
To mitigate these effects, pet owners should be encouraged to learn about canine behavior from reputable sources. Understanding the emotional and psychological needs of dogs can foster healthier relationships and improve overall well-being for both pets and their owners.
The Role of Education in Responsible Pet Ownership
Education plays a critical role in promoting responsible pet ownership and awareness of breed-specific issues. Research indicates that informed owners are more likely to provide appropriate care and training, which can mitigate behavioral problems and improve the quality of life for both the pet and the owner.
Programs aimed at educating potential dog owners about breed characteristics and needs can lead to better matches between dogs and families, fostering healthier relationships.
The American Kennel Club has weird ideas about how these dogs should look
People can't even recognize real German Shepherds anymore.
French bulldogs also have issues
A behavioral psychologist notes that the social context in which dog ownership occurs significantly influences perceptions of different breeds. For example, a study conducted by researchers at UC Berkeley found that social status and cultural perceptions play a crucial role in how different breeds are valued and evaluated. This means that in communities where certain breeds are considered 'trendy,' owners may overlook the health implications associated with those breeds, focusing instead on their social prestige. This phenomenon can lead to a cycle where the popularity of certain breeds overshadows important conversations about their health and well-being.
To counteract this trend, community-based initiatives aimed at educating prospective dog owners about the realities of breed-specific health risks can be vital. By fostering a culture of responsibility and informed decision-making, communities can shift the focus from status to the welfare of animals.
Moreover, understanding the importance of adopting rather than buying can help combat the issues surrounding unethical breeding. The Humane Society emphasizes that adopting from shelters can save lives while also promoting the adoption of mixed-breed dogs, which tend to have fewer health issues compared to purebreds.
Encouraging this practice can lead to a cultural shift away from the idea that certain breeds are inherently superior.
Cavalier King Charles Spaniels
Small dog syndrome
Wiener dogs
Understanding breed-specific health issues also ties into the psychological principle of empathy. Research shows that fostering empathy towards animals can significantly influence adoption and care practices. According to a study from the University of Michigan, individuals who engage in empathy-building exercises—such as volunteering at animal shelters or fostering dogs—are more likely to support responsible breeding practices and advocate for animal welfare. When people develop a deeper emotional connection with animals, they tend to prioritize the well-being of those animals over societal expectations or trends.
To enhance empathy among potential dog owners, animal welfare organizations can implement programs that encourage hands-on experiences with various breeds, highlighting the unique needs and challenges associated with each. This approach can promote a more compassionate understanding of the responsibilities that come with dog ownership.
The Psychological Effects of Breed Stigmatization
Stigmatizing certain breeds can have negative psychological effects on both the dogs and their owners. Research from the University of Washington suggests that owners of stigmatized breeds often experience social isolation and judgment from the community.
Such stigma can lead to anxiety and stress for both the owner and the dog, as they navigate societal perceptions and potential discrimination.
They suffer from back problems
When choosing a furry companion, it is useful to know which breeds are known for health issues. While purebred dogs are appealing for their characteristic traits, the selective breeding process also leads to the prevalence of a variety of inherited diseases within breeds.
Different breeds are predisposed to problems such as cataracts, hip dysplasia, and cancer. Reputable breeders often offer health guarantees, but some diseases are difficult to predict at young ages.
The best course of action is to avoid getting one of the breeds people have mentioned above, which would spare you the torture of seeing your pet suffer.
To combat this stigma, community education initiatives can play a vital role. Programs that promote positive stories and characteristics of often-maligned breeds can help shift public perception and reduce fear-based responses.
Encouraging open dialogue about breed behavior can foster understanding and acceptance, ultimately benefiting both the animals and their owners.
The Need for Ethical Considerations in Breeding
Addressing the ethical considerations surrounding dog breeding requires a concerted effort from all stakeholders involved. Researchers advocate for guidelines that prioritize the health and well-being of the animals over aesthetic traits and breed standards.
According to a study published in the Journal of Animal Ethics, ethical breeding practices should emphasize the welfare of the dog rather than financial profit.
Implementing stricter regulations and promoting responsible breeding practices can help alleviate the health issues that many breeds face today. Involvement from veterinary professionals and animal welfare organizations is crucial in establishing these guidelines and ensuring compliance.
By prioritizing the welfare of dogs, society can work towards a future where all breeds are valued for their unique qualities rather than their marketability.
Encouraging Responsible Breeding Practices
Promoting responsible breeding practices involves educating breeders and the public about the long-term impacts of their choices. Research indicates that transparency and accountability in breeding can lead to healthier dog populations.
For example, breed clubs can set standards that emphasize genetic health testing and responsible breeding protocols to mitigate health risks associated with certain breeds.
Ultimately, fostering an understanding of these issues is essential for creating a more ethical culture surrounding dog ownership. By advocating for responsible practices and promoting education, individuals can contribute to the welfare of dogs and the integrity of the breeding community.
Advancing this understanding can lead to a future where all dogs, regardless of breed, are treated with respect and compassion.
Psychological Analysis
This discourse reflects the complex interplay between breeding practices and the ethical responsibilities of owners. Understanding the psychological impacts of breed stigmatization can inspire a shift towards more compassionate attitudes and behaviors in society.
Analysis generated by AI
Analysis & Alternative Approaches
In conclusion, the discussions surrounding dog breeds and their ethical implications highlight the need for responsible breeding and ownership. Research supports the notion that education and awareness can lead to better outcomes for dogs and their owners alike.
By prioritizing the welfare of animals and challenging stigmas, society can work towards a more inclusive environment for all breeds, fostering compassion and understanding.
Share this article:
