Stray Cat Chooses New Family, But Her Original Owner Isn’t Ready To Let Go
It started with an adorable kitty showing up at a couple’s door one spring morning. She was tiny, gentle, and surprisingly affectionate for what seemed like a stray.
Before long, the little cat became part of their daily life, stopping by every morning and night, curling up on the couch, and napping beside their two resident cats.
The woman (OP) and her boyfriend didn’t think much of it at first. They’d feed her, give her treats, and let her hang around the house.
But after a few weeks, the woman began to suspect something: the cat looked pregnant. When they went on vacation and came back, the cat was thinner, and it seemed clear she had given birth somewhere nearby.
Wanting to do the right thing, they took her to the vet, planning to officially adopt her. That’s when they learned she had indeed been nursing kittens recently.
OP decided to follow the cat one afternoon, only to discover where she had kept her kittens…on their neighbor’s patio. What a real bummer!
The neighbor claimed the cat as hers, saying she fed her milk and considered her an outdoor cat.
She didn’t seem concerned about vet visits or spaying and even offered OP and her boyfriend two kittens as a “thank you” for everything they had done.
But after spending months caring for the mother cat, paying for her vet visit, and watching her bond with their pets, OP can’t shake the feeling that the cat belongs with them.
Now, with their move out of state approaching, they’re torn between doing what feels right by taking the cat along or saying their final goodbyes.
Scroll through the screenshots below to read the full story.
Let’s dig into the details
OP and her boyfriend were getting regular visits from a female cat. Over time, they socialized it with their own cats, and it became a family friend
OP finally decided to adopt the kitty. But in the process, she found out that the kitty belongs to her neighbor
Expert Insights on Feline Behavior
Dr. John Bradshaw, a renowned cat behaviorist and author, emphasizes that cats often choose their human companions based on reliability and emotional connection. As he details on his website, johnbradshaw.cat, cats are highly perceptive to the emotional states of people, which influences their attachment.
This is particularly relevant in the case of stray cats, who may find security in the presence of kind humans. Dr. Bradshaw notes that if a cat forms a bond with someone, it's essential for potential owners to respect that relationship.
Practical Solutions for Stray Cats
Experts recommend that anyone involved with a stray cat consult local animal welfare organizations to gain insights on the best practices for caring for such animals. For instance, spaying or neutering stray cats is crucial to prevent overpopulation, according to the ASPCA.
Furthermore, they suggest establishing a feeding schedule and a safe space for the cat, reducing the likelihood of it feeling the need to roam between homes. By collaborating with neighbors and local shelters, families can develop a sustainable approach to managing the stray animal population in their community.
OP and the neighbor have been going back and forth ever since she discovered that the neighbor doesn’t have any proof of ownership
OP and her boyfriend would be moving out of state pretty soon, and she wants to know if it’s right to take the cat along without informing the neighbor, who can’t prove ownership
We gathered some interesting comments from the Reddit community
Wildlife experts suggest that the concept of ownership can be complex when it comes to stray animals. According to a report by the Humane Society, many communities face challenges in determining pet ownership, especially with cats who roam freely.
They recommend that if someone finds a stray cat, they should first check for a microchip and try to locate the original owner before claiming the pet as their own. This not only honors the bond formed between the cat and its prior owner but also fosters responsible pet ownership in communities.
“Nta for taking her. BUT if you don't take the kittens too, you're an a**hole.”
“The cat does not belong to your neighbor. Its a random stray they happen to occasionally feed and that's it.”
“NTA. Take the cat back to the vet, get her fixed and microchipped.”
The Emotional Impact on Pets
Dr. Patricia McConnell, an animal behaviorist, explains that animals, much like humans, experience emotions tied to their relationships. As detailed on her site, patriciamcconnell.com, pets can feel a sense of loss or confusion when their living arrangements change.
This emotional upheaval can lead to stress or behavioral issues in pets. For families navigating a similar situation, McConnell suggests introducing gradual transitions, such as allowing the cat to visit both homes, to help it adjust to new living arrangements while minimizing anxiety.
“If you're able, swipe the kittens and work on finding homes for them. Legally, the neighbor doesn't own the cat or kittens.”
“But I would hope you would not just leave her kittens there and try to find homes for them as well.”
“But I would hope you would not just leave her kittens there and try to find homes for them as well.”
As stray cats often form bonds with more than one household, the rules of pet ownership can become blurry. A relationship expert noted that the emotional connections formed by these animals are valid and deserve acknowledgment.
To prevent conflicts like the one described, it’s essential for communities to create a shared understanding of pet ownership. Establishing community guidelines around stray animal care can help mitigate confusion and encourage cooperative relationships among neighbors.
This one’s tough because both sides have some claim to the cat. The neighbor may see the kitty as “hers,” but it’s clear OP has been doing all the real caretaking.
In addition, OP noted that the neighbor still hasn’t been able to provide any proof of ownership, which makes her claim a bit suspicious.
The cat herself seems to have already made her choice, and that complicates everything.
Whether taking her would be wrong or simply compassionate depends on how you see ownership when it comes to animals that roam freely.
What do you think? Should the couple take the cat or leave her behind?
Expert Opinion
This situation really highlights the emotional complexities in human-animal relationships. The couple's attachment to the cat likely stems from their consistent care and bonding, which can create a sense of ownership beyond just legal claims. Meanwhile, the neighbor's perspective might reflect a desire for connection, even if it’s more about feeding than genuine caretaking, showing how different interpretations of responsibility can lead to conflict.Research-Based Understanding
Navigating the complexities of stray animal ownership requires sensitivity and understanding. Research by experts like Dr. John Bradshaw and Dr. Patricia McConnell highlights the emotional bonds formed between cats and their caretakers, emphasizing the need for thoughtful communication among neighbors.
Communities can benefit from collaborative guidelines that promote responsible pet ownership and support for stray animals. By fostering a culture of care that respects existing relationships, we can create environments where both pets and their humans thrive together.
Share this article:
