AITA For Wanting To Sell My Girlfriend's Dog After It Bit Me | Reddit Post

by Sophia

13 Sep 2025

In a recent Reddit post, a user sought advice on whether they were in the wrong for wanting to sell their girlfriend's dog after it bit them. The OP, who recently moved in with their girlfriend, had an altercation with the dog while trying to enforce a no-furniture rule they had set.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

The dog ended up biting them, causing a minor injury. The OP's reaction led to a heated argument with their girlfriend, who refused to give up the dog.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

The situation escalated when the OP attempted to sell the dog behind their girlfriend's back, leading to further conflict and potentially jeopardizing their relationship. As the Reddit community weighed in, many commenters unanimously agreed that the OP was at fault for mishandling the situation.

They criticized the OP for trying to control the dog and enforce rules in a space that wasn't solely theirs. The consensus was that the OP's actions, including attempting to sell the dog without consent and belittling their girlfriend's attachment to her pet, were inappropriate and disrespectful.

Commenters highlighted the importance of understanding and respecting existing relationships, as well as the need to approach conflicts with empathy and consideration for all parties involved.

Original Post

Okay, so for context, I (m33) have been dating my girlfriend (f29) for almost a year and recently moved in with her about 2 months ago. Everything was fine until last week when her dog (a pitbull mix; I don’t really care about breeds) bit me on the wrist after I tried to drag him off the couch.

He growled at me, so I grabbed his collar to pull him off (he’s not allowed on furniture; I made that clear when I moved in), and he just turned and bit me. Not super deep, but it bled, and now I have this nasty scab, and it’s still sore.

I yelled and kicked the coffee table, and the dog ran off. She came running and got all mad at me like I provoked him or something. I told her that was BS and that the dog is dangerous and we need to get rid of him—either to the pound or sell him to someone who knows how to control animals.

She freaked out and said he’s never bitten anyone in 5 years and that *I* scared him. She wouldn’t stop crying and made this huge scene like I’d asked her to get rid of the dog or whatever.

I said it’s just a dog; she can get another one later when we have a house and a yard. She refused, locked herself in the bedroom with the dog (???) and I had to sleep on the couch for 2 nights.

I tried to make it right by calling a buddy of mine who works with a breeder and asking if he knew anyone who might take the dog for like $200. I figured I’d just make the decision and deal with her being mad later since she was acting all emotional and not rational.

Well, she found out because I guess he texted her instead of me (thanks, bro), and now she’s furious—like full-on packing her stuff mad. I told her she was overreacting and that this was a health issue (I could’ve gotten infected or worse!) and that if she was really serious about me, she’d pick my safety over a mutt.

Now she won’t talk to me and told me to stay at my mom’s while she “thinks things over.” She’s posted some passive-aggressive story about betrayal and “protecting those who can’t speak,” and our friends are blowing up my phone saying I was out of line. I don’t know.

I still feel like I did what any sane person would do. A dog bites you; you don’t just ignore it.

I didn’t even hurt the dog. I just tried to move him off furniture that he shouldn't even be on!

Am I really the bad guy for trying to sell a dog that bit me? AITA?

Edit: Okay. So.

I’ve read through the comments, had some time to sit with this, and yeah—I see now that I was a complete AH here. No sugarcoating it.

First off, I want to start by owning the fact that I came into *her* home, *her* space, and tried to enforce rules like it was automatically mine too. That was disrespectful.

The dog lived there before me. The couch wasn’t mine.

And me deciding that the dog “isn’t allowed on furniture” like I was laying down the law in a place I just moved into? That was arrogant.

Second—and this is big—I *absolutely* mishandled the situation with her dog. Grabbing a dog by the collar, especially one that’s growling?

That’s on me. That’s not “controlling the situation”; that’s provoking fear and setting myself up to get bitten.

I acted like I knew what I was doing around animals when I clearly didn’t. I didn't even ask how she normally handles that stuff.

I just went full bulldozer mode. And yeah, trying to sell *her* dog behind her back?

That was beyond messed up. I was frustrated and scared after getting bitten, yeah—but that doesn’t justify violating someone’s trust like that.

That dog isn’t just “a mutt”; it’s her *family.* I didn’t get that at the time, but I do now. If someone tried to sell my car without asking, I’d flip—and that’s just a car.

A dog is a living creature, one she’s clearly bonded with for years. And I tried to handle it like it was a Craigslist transaction.

Also, calling her “emotional” and “irrational” when she was reacting to me threatening something she loves? That was cruel.

I dismissed her feelings when really I should’ve been asking how to make it right. I didn’t even check in on the dog.

I just went into crisis control like I was in charge of fixing something that I *caused.*

So yeah. I get why she’s furious.

I’d be too. I came in hot, didn’t listen, tried to dominate the situation, and then doubled down when called out.

Total AH behavior. I’m not here to make excuses.

I just wanted to say that I *do* get it now. And if she’s reading this—I’m sorry.

Deeply. For the fear I caused, the betrayal, and not treating your dog like the living, trusting being he is.

You were protecting someone who *couldn’t* speak, and I was treating him like a problem to be solved, not like a soul that needed care. I don’t know if we’re going to make it through this, but I hope you and your pup are okay.

I was wrong. And I’m sorry.

Understanding Emotional Reactions to Pets

Pets often become integral members of the family, and emotional reactions to their behavior can be quite intense. Research shows that interactions with pets can evoke strong feelings of attachment and love, as noted in studies from the Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science. In this case, the desire to sell the dog after being bitten may reflect a protective instinct rather than a lack of affection.

Understanding the emotional weight of this decision can help clarify motivations and guide actions in a way that honors both the pet's needs and personal boundaries.

The Emotional Landscape of Pet Ownership

Desiring to sell a girlfriend's dog after being bitten highlights the emotional complexities of pet ownership within relationships. Research in the Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science indicates that pets often become integral parts of family dynamics, serving as sources of companionship and emotional support. When an incident like a bite occurs, it can trigger strong emotional reactions, leading to feelings of fear, anger, and even betrayal.

This situation illustrates how pet ownership can intertwine with relationship dynamics, complicating feelings and decisions.

Comment from u/Automatic_Drawer_884

Comment from u/Paddfoot13

Feelings of distress following a pet bite highlight the psychological concept of fear response. Research indicates that traumatic experiences with animals can lead to heightened anxiety and avoidance behaviors, particularly if the individual has had prior negative interactions with pets. Recognizing how these experiences can shape emotional responses can be beneficial in navigating this situation.

Addressing feelings of fear and anxiety through open communication can help create a more supportive environment for both partners.

Comment from u/Visual-Usual-48

Comment from u/bastetandisis9

Moreover, studies show that pets can evoke deep emotional attachments, making decisions about their future particularly challenging. According to the American Psychological Association, pets are often viewed as family members, and decisions surrounding them can evoke similar emotional responses as those related to human family members. Understanding this emotional connection is crucial when navigating conflicts involving pets.

Comment from u/[deleted]

Comment from u/Easy_Huckleberry_171

The Role of Communication in Resolving Conflicts

Effective communication is essential when navigating conflicts surrounding pets. According to research published in the American Psychological Association, open dialogue can lead to healthier outcomes in family discussions. When addressing the desire to sell the dog, framing it as a means of ensuring safety may help mitigate potential backlash and promote understanding.

Using 'I' statements to express feelings about the incident can help convey personal emotions without placing blame, creating a safer space for discussion.

Comment from u/kryten_69

Comment from u/km4098

Navigating Conflict with Compassion

In situations involving pets, fostering open communication is essential. Research highlights that individuals often have different perspectives on pet ownership, which can lead to misunderstandings. Engaging in discussions about feelings surrounding the incident can help clarify intentions and promote empathy. Studies in family psychology emphasize the importance of understanding each other’s emotional attachments to pets to resolve conflicts effectively.

By acknowledging each other's feelings, both partners can work towards a resolution that respects their emotional investments.

Comment from u/Rimuru_The_Junior

Comment from u/EaglePotential259

The emotional bond between humans and pets can complicate decisions surrounding their care. Research indicates that the attachment to pets can lead to feelings of guilt when considering rehoming them. Understanding this emotional complexity can help partners navigate discussions about the dog's future more empathetically.

Recognizing that both emotions regarding the pet's behavior and the love for the pet itself can coexist may help facilitate a more constructive conversation.

Comment from u/Harrymoto1970

Comment from u/Becalmandkind

Additionally, the incident of being bitten may trigger underlying fears related to safety and trust within the relationship. Research in the Journal of Interpersonal Violence indicates that such experiences can lead to heightened anxiety and conflict in relationships. Understanding how these feelings can influence behavior is crucial for navigating the aftermath of such incidents.

Comment from u/BrushIndependent5210

Comment from u/[deleted]

Practical Steps for Addressing the Situation

When discussing the possibility of selling the dog, it may be helpful to approach the conversation with empathy and understanding. Consider setting aside time to discuss the incident and feelings surrounding it, allowing both partners to express their perspectives openly.

Exploring alternatives to rehoming, such as training or behavior modification, can also provide a more constructive path forward while addressing safety concerns. Engaging a professional trainer may help alleviate fears and create a safer living environment.

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

In conclusion, conflicts surrounding pet ownership can evoke strong emotional responses that reflect deeper relationship dynamics. Psychological research underscores the importance of empathy and open communication in resolving these conflicts. By fostering understanding and collaboration, couples can navigate these challenges and strengthen their emotional connection.

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Navigating conflicts surrounding pets requires sensitivity and understanding. Recognizing the emotional complexities involved can foster healthier discussions and lead to more constructive outcomes.

By prioritizing open communication and exploring collaborative solutions, couples can strengthen their relationships while ensuring the well-being of their pets.

The Importance of Compromise in Relationships

To navigate these complex emotions, finding a compromise that respects both partners' feelings is essential. Research indicates that compromise can enhance relationship satisfaction and emotional connection. For instance, exploring alternatives like seeking professional training for the dog or discussing rehoming options that consider both partners' comfort levels can lead to a more satisfactory resolution.

By working collaboratively, couples can foster a sense of partnership in addressing conflicts related to pets.

What would you do in this situation? Share your opinion in the comments.

Ultimately, decisions about pets can serve as reflections of deeper relational dynamics. Psychological insights emphasize the importance of compassion and understanding in these discussions. By prioritizing open dialogue and emotional awareness, couples can navigate conflicts more effectively and strengthen their relationship.

Ultimately, prioritizing the emotional well-being of both partners and the pet is crucial. By fostering open communication and exploring collaborative solutions, couples can navigate these challenging situations with greater ease and understanding.

Encouraging ongoing discussions about pet care and safety can strengthen relationships and create a more harmonious home environment.

Share this article: