logo
Animals Cats Dogs Our Channels Our Authors

Lady’s Refusal To Have Her Childhood Dog Cremated Causes Family Issues

Stephanie
by Stephanie
10 Oct 2022

Dogs are well-known for providing unconditional love. Having a dog means you'll always have a little living being waiting for you at home, ready to greet you with a wagging tail or a purr.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

A beloved dog's death can be a heartbreaking time in any owner's life. There is nothing that truly prepares you for losing the animal you love, whether it is sudden or you have had time to prepare.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

So it's critical that we remember our dogs in the best way possible after they've died, and fortunately, there are many unique ways to commemorate their lives. From creative handmade knits to engraved jewelry, or even burying them and planting a tree on their graves, there are many options.

Meet this Redditor, u/MadisonMarie123, whose beloved childhood dog passed away. The dog, Lilly, actually lived out its lifespan, but it was still heartbreaking for the owner.

The Redditor planned to bury her beloved dog and plant a tree on the grave, as this would please her. However, it turned into a more distressing situation for the owner when her mother's family demanded she cremate the dog in line with her death wish.

Scroll down to read how the whole story unfolded and how it resulted in the OP sharing the story with the AITA for their opinions. We have put together snapshots from the original post and comments for you to read in detail.

This Redditor has refused to heed her mom's wishes by getting her dog cremated

This Redditor has refused to heed her mom's wishes by getting her dog cremated
u/MadisonMarie123
[ADVERTISEMENT]

Losing my first dog was awful for me

Losing my first dog was awful for me
u/MadisonMarie123

She's done this type of thing for years

She's done this type of thing for years
u/MadisonMarie123

The Intersection of Grief and Decision-Making

Dr. Christie Lane, a psychologist at the University of Toronto, explores the emotional complexities of grief and its impact on decision-making.

Her research suggests that grief can cloud judgment, often making it difficult for individuals to make rational choices during emotionally charged situations.

Understanding these dynamics can provide insight into the challenges faced when making decisions about end-of-life preferences for pets.

My mom's dog started to have health issues

My mom's dog started to have health issues
u/MadisonMarie123

She also stated she was becoming a little snippy

She also stated she was becoming a little snippy
u/MadisonMarie123

It was the first time I was hearing this plan of hers

It was the first time I was hearing this plan of hers
u/MadisonMarie123

Studies in bereavement psychology indicate that individuals may struggle to honor their deceased loved ones' wishes while also managing their emotional responses.

This internal conflict can lead to feelings of guilt and confusion, particularly when family expectations are involved.

Recognizing this struggle is essential for navigating the grieving process and making informed decisions.

As expected, Redditors had their opinions regarding this story, and we've gathered some of their responses for you below.

Your family is massively overreacting

Your family is massively overreacting
Reddit

This info really needed to be clarified

This info really needed to be clarified
Reddit

This Redditor apparently needed the above info too

This Redditor apparently needed the above info too
Reddit

Navigating Family Expectations and Grief

Family dynamics can significantly influence decisions surrounding grief and loss.

Research shows that when families have differing expectations about how to honor a deceased loved one, it can lead to conflict and emotional distress.

Understanding these dynamics is crucial for fostering open communication and healing within the family.

It's good you now know your mom's wishes

It's good you now know your mom's wishes
Reddit

You choose how to take care of your dog

You choose how to take care of your dog
Reddit

OP's mom forgot that it isn't her dog

OP's mom forgot that it isn't her dog
Reddit

A practical step for the woman is to openly discuss her feelings about her late sister's wishes with family members.

Engaging in a dialogue about the emotional weight of these decisions can help clarify expectations and reduce tension.

Additionally, seeking support from a counselor who specializes in grief can provide valuable insights into navigating these complex emotions.

It's not really reasonable to call you selfish

It's not really reasonable to call you selfish
Reddit

Does this clarify anything or just make it weirder?

Does this clarify anything or just make it weirder?
Reddit

This Redditor just had to know who cremates a dog???

This Redditor just had to know who cremates a dog???
Reddit

Protect your babies both here and gone

Protect your babies both here and gone
Reddit

There are few things as horrifying as this

There are few things as horrifying as this
Reddit

You have done everything good with grace for your dog

You have done everything good with grace for your dog
Reddit

She can still be released into the mountains

She can still be released into the mountains
Reddit

They were never the primary caregiver

They were never the primary caregiver
Reddit

Is that really so awful?

Is that really so awful?
Reddit

This Redditor has never heard of something like this before

This Redditor has never heard of something like this before
Reddit

Dogs are known for their unconditional love for their owners and even the people around them. That’s exactly why their deaths can affect everyone connected to them, and sometimes it can unsettle the family, as we have seen in this case.

It’s truly a moment in pet ownership that every pet lover dreads. Let us know your fears about owning pets in the comments below.

Psychological Analysis

This situation illustrates the emotional complexities of managing grief alongside family expectations.

Recognizing the importance of dialogue and support can facilitate healthier decision-making processes during difficult times.

Analysis generated by AI

Analysis & Alternative Approaches

Navigating grief and family expectations requires sensitivity and understanding.

Research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology emphasizes the importance of clear communication in resolving conflicts related to grief.

Share this article:

Facebook icon Pinterest icon Tumblr icon Link icon Twitter icon

Related Articles

Dog Owner Investigates Barking and Discovers Baby Koala Hitching a Ride on His Golden Retriever's Back

Dog Owner Investigates Barking and Discovers Baby Koala Hitching a Ride on His Golden Retriever's Back

The Great Escape — Turtle Found 5 Miles Away From Home After Going Missing For 3 Years

The Great Escape — Turtle Found 5 Miles Away From Home After Going Missing For 3 Years

Fun Outing Turns Sour As Owner's Dog Scared Customer And Made Him Drop Drink

Fun Outing Turns Sour As Owner's Dog Scared Customer And Made Him Drop Drink

Sister Chooses Free Weekend Over Helping Out—Declines Bridesmaid’s Request to Petsit for Wedding

Sister Chooses Free Weekend Over Helping Out—Declines Bridesmaid’s Request to Petsit for Wedding

This Goldendoodle’s Heartwarming First Encounter With His Baby Brother Will Melt Your Heart In Seconds

This Goldendoodle’s Heartwarming First Encounter With His Baby Brother Will Melt Your Heart In Seconds

50 Touching Then And Now Pics Of Pets And Their Owners That Will Melt Your Heart

50 Touching Then And Now Pics Of Pets And Their Owners That Will Melt Your Heart

Brave Officers Take Heroic Dive Into Vile, Muck-Ridden Sewage Drain To Retrieve Adorable Puppy Trapped Inside

Brave Officers Take Heroic Dive Into Vile, Muck-Ridden Sewage Drain To Retrieve Adorable Puppy Trapped Inside

The Impact Of The Magical Story Of Yoda, The Persian Cat Lives On Even After His Demise

The Impact Of The Magical Story Of Yoda, The Persian Cat Lives On Even After His Demise

[ADVERTISEMENT]

Categories

Animals Cats Dogs

Business

About Us Advertise Contact Us

Legal

Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy DMCA Removal
 Logo
About Us Privacy DMCA Removal Terms Fact Checking Policy Contact Us Our Authors Our Channels Animals Cats Dogs

© 2026 - All Rights Reserved