People Answer If Dogs That Go For Scraps Of Food Are Actually Still Hungry or If They Just Eat Because It Is There
It always starts the same way, someone drops a scrap, a dog rockets over like the food is a limited-time emergency, and suddenly everyone is debating whether the pup is starving or just doing what dogs do.
In this Quora thread, the whole thing gets messy fast. One person says it is normal, pack and hunting instinct, their dog grabs whatever hits the floor no matter what meal just happened. Another person shares the “hiccup” moment, a Lab snatching a piece of hot chili and then bulldozing through wet grass with his face. Then there is the training angle, a dog that ignores ground food because the owner told him not to, and the warning that it could be meds, not dinner.
And that is the real question hiding under the crumbs, is your dog actually hungry, or have you just turned the floor into the buffet table.
Here is the original question that was posted on Quora. This sounds like something many dog owners have experienced before.
We'd be worried if they weren't eating everything too because that's just what dogs do.
As per Joanne’s good answer - I would be more worried if the dogs did NOT naturally try to grab any scraps that fall; that is perfectly normal behavior, probably stemming from hunting/pack instinct. It really never made a difference with mine whether they had just been fed or not, so all is well.
The only time there was a ‘hiccup’ was when my Lab grabbed what I accidentally dropped while prepping food - it was a piece of hot chili. Ever see a Lab trying to ‘plow’ along wet grass with his face for a while? Well, I did!
The next ‘windfall’ was carefully sniffed first!
It is also true that if dogs have been allowed to do it before, they will most likely continue doing it.
They do it because they have never been trained not to. Hungry or not, the dog should not touch anything that falls on the floor. What if it's one of your medications that could harm a dog if ingested?
My dog will ignore anything that falls unless I tell him to get it because he has been trained that way.
He will also ignore food found on the ground anywhere due to that training; I like my dog alive and well.
Dogs are definitely binge eaters - we have to agree.
Dogs are binge eaters. In the wild, this is a beneficial adaptation that prevents wasted food.
In a domestic setting, this only leads to overweight dogs.
Your pups will *always* act hungry around any food; it is your parental responsibility to limit their intake.
This comment answered it pretty well in our opinion!
All dogs and wild canids are “opportunistic” predators and will take advantage of a food source whenever one presents itself, quickly gorging themselves to the bursting point to ensure they can carry some back to regurgitate for the older dogs and pups left behind at the den while the younger, fitter pack members hunt…
Domesticated dogs retain those instincts, and humans who allow their dogs to “free feed” are the largest contributors to the greatest health problem across all breeds… obesity…
So… your dogs dive for those food scraps for two reasons…
They are hard-wired by 37 million years of evolution and 30,000 years of scavenging meals from human garbage dumps to do so…
You have failed to train them to keep a respectful distance from the human kitchen and dinner table…
The moment the Lab grabbed hot chili while prepping food, the whole “are they hungry” debate stopped being theoretical and became a very wet-grass spectacle.
It also echoes the dog owner who tried to decode their pet’s weird behavior right after dinner.
After Joanne’s point about grabbing scraps being perfectly normal, the thread shifts from hunger to habit, and whether dogs keep doing it once they learn it is allowed.
Then the medication warning lands, because the stakes change instantly when the “scrap” could be something that should never touch a dog’s mouth.
By the time someone mentions their dog ignoring anything that falls because of training, the question flips from “why are they eating” to “why are they getting the chance.”
Dogs are definitely heavy eaters, and they are not always hungry, but they won't pass up food if it's in front of them. Most dogs aren't actually hungry, but they do have the instincts to continue eating, and it's the owner's responsibility to keep their intake at a reasonable amount.
The family dinner might be over, but for your dog, the floor is still open for business.
For a totally different kind of dog-food meltdown, read about the owner who wanted to put her dog down after it ate kids' meals.
Share this article:
