Cat Parent Takes In Stray Tuxedo Cat, Then Stays Silent After Learning Owner Has Been Frantically Searching For It
A 28-year-old woman didn’t “find” a cat so much as accidentally adopt one, and then she made a choice that has Reddit side-eyeing her hard. The cat in question is a tuxedo cat, the kind that looks like it’s dressed for a fancy dinner, and it belonged to someone else who was actively searching.
Here’s the messy part: OP took the stray in, noticed it was clearly owned, and saw the owner’s Facebook post about a missing cat. Instead of turning the cat in, she refused, allegedly pretended she didn’t see the post, and kept the cat anyway. To make it worse, commenters pointed out the cat had tapeworms and wasn’t in great shape, which made everyone argue about neglect, responsibility, and legality.
Now the whole thread is stuck on one brutal question: did OP save a neglected cat, or just ignore a family’s desperate search?
Let’s dig into the details
A bit of backstory
OP discovered that the cat she took in belonged to someone else, and the owner had put up a post on facebook her missing cat
OP refused turning in the cat and even pretended like they didn’t see the facebook post
Important edit
We gathered some interesting reactions from the Reddit community
“Owners who don't meet basic veterinary needs or have a pet microchiped shouldn't be responsible for an animal's life.”
This echoes the sister who called her brother a b*tch for stealing an old woman’s cat.
“Considering that the cat had tapeworms and wasn't in good shape indicates that it was neglected.”
“The woman was a bad pet owner for not neutering or microchipping her cat.”
“The cat is better off with a non-neglectful owner who will keep it inside and get it proper medical care.”
“He wasn't neutered and had frickin untreated worms. NTA, keep your new cat.”
“If you could figure out a way to let her know her cat is safe without stirring up trouble, you should try.”
OP found the Facebook missing-cat post, then acted like it didn’t exist, and that’s where the comments started sharpening their knives.
Once Redditors zoomed in on the tapeworms and the cat’s condition, the story stopped being “stray rescue” and turned into “who dropped the ball.”
People also got hung up on the missing basics, like neutering and microchipping, because that’s what made the owner look careless to the crowd.
Even the reactions that defended OP still landed on the same awkward moment, the one where she could have quietly told the family the cat was safe.
From the information about the Facebook post, it’s obvious that the family is heartbroken about losing their beloved pet.
However, the neglect that the cat suffered makes it easy for Netizens to tilt towards OP’s side.
Ultimately, it all boils down to the legality of OP’s actions. As one Redditor suggested, it may be best for OP to reach out to the owner and inform them of the current situation of her cat.
What would you do if you were in this position? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
The tuxedo cat may be living better now, but OP’s decision is still sitting in the middle of the family’s heartbreak.
Wait, it gets worse, like the rescuer who neutered a beloved pet without permission.
Share this article:
