Declining Thanksgiving Invitation Due to Pets: AITA or Setting Boundaries?

by Holly

2025-03-24 06:15

Are you the jerk for declining your sister's Thanksgiving invite due to her cats and dogs? Every year, a couple rotates between their families for Thanksgiving.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

This year, it was supposed to be with the guy's family, hosted by his parents. However, his sister and her husband wanted to host, and when he declined due to not liking animals, it caused chaos - with names like "asshole" thrown his way.

[ADVERTISEMENT]

He finds it gross that his sister's cats roam freely, even on the kitchen counters, and her dog is poorly behaved, jumping on people. When asked to attend if the animals were kept away and the kitchen cleaned, his sister found it disrespectful.

The guy stood his ground, but his sister and parents are upset. The Reddit thread is filled with diverse opinions - some say he's in the right for setting boundaries, while others criticize his approach as tactless.

The debate touches on family dynamics, pet ownership, hygiene, and holiday traditions. It's a nuanced situation where personal preferences clash with family expectations, prompting a lively discussion on boundaries and communication.

Original Post

Every year my (35M) wife and I rotate who's family we go to for thanksgiving. One year mine, the next year hers.
This year is due to be with my family. Typically my parents host.
This year my sister (29F) and husband asked to host and my parents okayed it. I declined and caused an uproar.

I've been called an a*****e, rude, etc. My sister loves animals, and well...
I don't. I rarely go to her house and when I do it's without my wife and kids.
1. I find the fact she lets her cats into the kitchen and on the counters really f*****g gross.

2. Her dog is super obnoxious, not all that well behaved.
It'll jump on you and that type of stuff. I wouldn't say it's dangerous, just annoying.
When the news about who is hosting came to me, I discussed it with my wife, said let's go to your families and my wife was good with that. I let my parents know and they said I was overreacting.

They love her dogs so in my opinion they have a distorted viewpoint. The news made it to my sister and she was not happy.
I told her we would come if the animals stayed in another room (and didn't come out at all) and I could clean the kitchen. She said I could clean all I wanted, but that was a disrespectful request to her family.
I told her that her pets are not family to me and I don't want to spend time with them. Ive left it with the fact that I'm not going to my sisters, but my sister and parents are upset with my decision.