Dog Lover Rehomes His Girlfriend's Cat Without Her Knowledge And Stole $7,500 Of Her Money To Buy 3 Dogs
Some people can live with a little pet rivalry, and some people turn it into a full-blown disaster. In this Reddit story, a dog-obsessed boyfriend crosses a line that no pet lover would forgive.
OP says her 21-year-old boyfriend, Sam, loved dogs so much that it became a problem. She was a cat person, but she thought their different preferences would be harmless, until he gave away her cat without permission, lied about what happened, and later stole $7,500 from her to buy three dogs.
Then the story got even messier, because Sam’s own version of events started making the rounds online. Read on.
After his dog died, Sam bought three dogs without letting OP know
They share a rental home, and he didn't even bother asking for her opinion. He brought home a gentle elderly dog and then later bought two energetic puppies for the low, low price of $7,500.
OP understands that it's not the puppies' fault if they destroy things, but what grinds her gears is her boyfriend's reaction to the mess. Sam refuses to train his dogs and even encourages bad behavior.
For example, when the dogs got ahold of OP's stuffed animals, Sam laughed and gave them another one to chew on. What he gave them was one of OP's rare stuffed toys that she worked hard to acquire.
They also pee on the carpets of their rental home instead of their pee pads because Sam doesn't potty train them. The lion's share of his dogs' care also falls on OP's shoulders.
Sam takes them for occasional walks, made Instagram accounts for the two puppies, and then called it a day. To top it all off, Sam only speaks in a "doggo voice" to everyone, including OP, which has affected their romantic life.
The biggest issue was only recently uncovered. OP keeps cash hidden away in their house for emergencies.
She took some to use for the elderly dog's vet bills, but when she checked on it again, most of her money was gone. She looked everywhere, but she couldn't find her emergency money.
OP asked Sam, the only other person in the house, who admitted to using OP's money to buy his puppies. OP gave him an ultimatum: give the puppies back and get a refund, or he can leave the house, which is under OP's name.
Sam refused to give up his dogs, so OP told him to go. She informed their landlord and asked him to change her locks.



The situation described highlights a fundamental psychological principle regarding relationship dynamics: the impact of differing values and priorities on a couple's compatibility. When one partner exhibits an extreme passion for a particular interest, such as Sam's devotion to dogs, it can overshadow other important aspects of the relationship, including mutual respect and compromise.
This imbalance can lead to significant distress, particularly when one partner feels marginalized or disregarded, as OP likely did when Sam rehomed her cat without consent. Understanding that relationships thrive on a foundation of shared values and open communication is crucial for long-term success.
That kind of mismatch can get ugly fast.



Empathy is a cornerstone of any healthy relationship, allowing partners to connect on an emotional level and understand each other's perspectives. In the case of OP and Sam, it appears that Sam's strong preference for dogs may have led him to neglect OP’s feelings and needs, resulting in a lack of empathy for her attachment to her cat.
Encouragingly, studies show that empathy can be cultivated through intentional practice. Couples can engage in exercises that promote understanding and active listening, thereby strengthening their emotional connection and minimizing conflict.
And this is where the trust really starts to crack.


Sam's parents came to his rescue after OP threatened to report him to the police. They paid her the full amount that Sam stole.

Sam's actions of rehoming the cat and stealing money to acquire dogs may be indicative of manipulative or controlling behaviors, which can undermine the foundation of trust in a relationship. OP's experience exemplifies how such behavior can lead to significant emotional upheaval and disillusionment.
Recognizing these patterns is paramount, as they can escalate and lead to more serious relational issues, including emotional abuse. Couples facing such challenges should consider seeking guidance from a therapist to navigate these complexities effectively.
Sam not rehoming his dogs is just a symptom of the real problem

OP clarified why her grandparents didn't immediately contact her when her boyfriend abandoned her cat in their home

By some twist of Reddit fate, someone found a post eerily similar to OP's situation

Financial issues often emerge as a significant source of conflict in relationships.
It’s a similar mess to the self-proclaimed animal lover who rehomed her dogs, then trained one behind her girlfriend’s back.
That excuse did not land well with Reddit.
It was written by the guy, and let's just say his version of events is... creative

According to this guy they believe is Sam, OP agreed to rehome her cat after an infected scratch

He also said when his dog destroyed OP's stuffed animal, his dog was doing her a favor

The violation of personal boundaries is a critical issue in this narrative.
OP apparently asked him to give away his dog since they were planning to move in together eventually

The difference in their post was a month. It ended with OP essentially kicking him out of the house.

After reading the now-deleted post, OP believes it is indeed her ex-boyfriend Sam

Conflict resolution is a crucial skill in maintaining healthy relationships, particularly when partners have opposing interests, as in the case of OP and Sam. Research indicates that couples who possess effective conflict resolution skills are better equipped to handle disagreements constructively, leading to improved relationship satisfaction (Markman et al., 2010). The lack of constructive dialogue in this scenario likely contributed to the escalation of issues, as Sam's decisions were made unilaterally and without consideration for OP's feelings.
Couples can develop conflict resolution skills through workshops or therapy, focusing on techniques such as active listening, expressing feelings without blame, and seeking collaborative solutions. By fostering these skills, partners can navigate disagreements more effectively and strengthen their bond.
Reddit was not buying his story for a second.
He totally lied, but other redditors didn't buy it

Did the cat really hate Sam?

Sam knew full well what OP's cat liked and didn't like, but he didn't respect the cat's boundaries

Shared interests play a vital role in relationship satisfaction and longevity., 2008). In the case of OP and Sam, their divergent preferences for pets may have created an emotional rift, as Sam's fervent love for dogs overshadowed OP's attachment to her cat.
Encouragingly, couples can work to find common ground by exploring new activities together that may align with both partners' interests. This can foster a sense of unity, allowing both individuals to feel valued and appreciated within the relationship.
In the ex-boyfriend's post, he got rightfully dragged for his thought process

He was called out for his unfairness and double standards as well

3 years old is not exactly a puppy, but calling the certified dog lover a mediocre dog owner was the best way to make him hurt

Phil the cat knew what was up with OP's ex

He got ripped a new one in the comments section of his post, and he deserved each one

People were asking why these two were together when they didn't even like each other. They couldn't communicate maturely about anything.
Thankfully, they have since broken up, and OP got her money back. We highly doubt that Sam changed his irresponsible ways since his parents just bailed him out of trouble.
The whole thing was a mess from the start, and Reddit knew it.
The dynamics illustrated in OP's situation reveal the complexities of human relationships, particularly when fundamental differences come into play.
Ultimately, relationships require mutual respect and cooperation. When partners prioritize each other's needs and work collaboratively to address challenges, they create a more stable and satisfying partnership. These efforts are not just beneficial but essential for long-term relationship success.
Before Sam bought three dogs, read about the dream dog that derailed a couple’s move-in decision.